Nightshades and Inflammation: Fact or Myth?

Few food claims spread as quickly as the idea that nightshade vegetables cause inflammation. Search online and you will find people who swear their skin or joints improved when they stopped eating tomatoes and potatoes, and plenty of others who noticed no difference at all. So is it fact or myth? The honest answer is somewhere in between, and it depends on the person.

What counts as a nightshade?

Nightshades are plants in the Solanaceae family. The edible ones are common in everyday cooking, which is why cutting them out is harder than it sounds.

NightshadesNot nightshades (despite the name or look)
Tomatoes and tomatillosSweet potatoes
Potatoes (white, red and yellow)Black and white pepper
AuberginesCourgettes and squash
Bell peppers and chilli peppersMushrooms
Paprika, cayenne and chilli powderOnions and garlic
Goji berriesBlueberries and other berries

Nightshades also hide in ketchup, pasta sauces, curry pastes, spice blends, salsa and many ready meals, so labels matter if you decide to test them.

Where the idea comes from

Nightshades contain natural compounds called glycoalkaloids, such as solanine in potatoes and tomatine in tomatoes. In large amounts, glycoalkaloids can be harmful, which is why green or sprouting potatoes should not be eaten. Some laboratory and animal research has suggested that potato glycoalkaloids may affect the lining of the gut, for example in mice bred to develop inflammatory bowel disease. Chilli peppers add capsaicin, which can irritate a sensitive stomach.

From there, the theory goes, these compounds might stir up inflammation elsewhere in the body. It is a plausible-sounding chain of ideas, but each link needs evidence from studies in people eating normal amounts of food, and that evidence is largely missing.

What studies in people show

There are no controlled trials testing nightshades in psoriasis. The most-quoted figure comes from a 2017 US survey of people with psoriasis, in which about half of those who cut out nightshades said their skin improved. That is worth taking seriously as a signal, but it was self-reported, there was no comparison group, and people who avoid nightshades often change other parts of their diet at the same time.

For arthritis, major patient organisations such as Versus Arthritis in the UK and Harvard Health in the US say there is no convincing evidence that nightshades worsen inflammation. Some research even points the other way: one small study found that men who ate pigmented potatoes for six weeks had lower markers of inflammation than those who ate white potatoes.

It is also worth remembering what nightshades bring to the plate. Tomatoes provide lycopene and vitamin C, red peppers are one of the richest vegetable sources of vitamin C, and potatoes eaten with their skins supply fibre and potassium.

TREAT app screen showing an avocado salad with tomatoes and red onion, with coach feedback
A salad with tomatoes and red onion scored well with our coach. Unless you notice a clear reaction, there is no need to pick out the tomatoes.

So, fact or myth?

As a blanket rule that nightshades cause inflammation, it is mostly myth. For most people they are nutritious foods with no proven link to flares. But individual reactions are possible. True allergies to tomato, potato or pepper exist, and some people with sensitive digestion find chilli or raw peppers uncomfortable. If you have a consistent suspicion, it is reasonable to test it carefully rather than cut nightshades out forever.

Not every reaction is inflammation

Sometimes a real reaction to nightshades has a simpler explanation. Tomatoes, tomato sauces and chilli are common triggers for heartburn and acid reflux, and spicy food can upset a sensitive gut. Those symptoms are uncomfortable, but they are not the same as an inflammatory flare of your skin or joints, and they are worth mentioning to your GP if they keep happening. If you do eat potatoes, store them in a cool, dark place and cut away any green patches or sprouts, where glycoalkaloids are most concentrated.

How to test nightshades fairly

  1. Record first. Keep a food and symptom diary for two to four weeks so you know your starting point. See our guide to keeping a food diary for autoimmune symptoms.
  2. Remove only nightshades. Keep the rest of your diet as normal, otherwise you will not know what made a difference.
  3. Swap, don't skip. Use sweet potato or squash instead of potato, courgette or mushrooms instead of aubergine, and black pepper, ginger, cumin or turmeric instead of chilli. Get vitamin C from citrus fruit, kiwi, broccoli and berries.
  4. Allow enough time. Skin changes slowly, so give the test several weeks.
  5. Bring them back one at a time. Reintroduce tomatoes for a few days, then potatoes, then peppers, and note what happens.
  6. Look at the whole picture. Stress, sleep, infections and the seasons all affect psoriasis, so check your diary for other changes before drawing conclusions.

If the results are unclear, you have learned something useful: nightshades are probably not your main trigger, and you can put your energy into changes with stronger evidence, such as those in foods that may trigger psoriasis flare-ups. For ideas on what to stock up on, see our beginner's anti-inflammatory shopping list.

Testing a food on your own can be confusing. With psoriasis diet coaching from TREAT, your coach can help you plan a fair test, keep your meals balanced while you do it, and make sense of the results.

Please note: this article is general information, not medical advice. Diet changes are not a replacement for the treatment your doctor or dermatologist recommends. Talk to them before making big changes, especially if you take prescribed medicines, are pregnant or have a history of disordered eating.

Navigate